Why Learning to Write Well in College is Difficult

1. Variations from discipline to discipline. Disciplines are discourse communities with their own methods of developing and communicating knowledge. However, students take classes in several disciplines (i.e., several discourse communities) at the same time and have difficulty mastering the different forms of inquiry and the different stylistic conventions that apply. It takes a long time to develop writing proficiency in one discipline—let alone several.
2. Lack of uniform criteria and standards. Criteria, standards, and definitions of good writing differ from course to course (even within the same department). Students develop the idea these are arbitrary and a matter of instructors’ personal preferences. This prompts them to search out “what you’re looking for” or “what you want” in their assignments.
3. Lack of explicit criteria and standards. In some courses, students have little or no information about what constitutes appropriate writing: no clear sense of the goal students are supposed to work toward.
4. Undeveloped writing processes. In many classes students are expected to write well, but are not taught to do so. Courses do not try to develop students’ writing: they simply require it. And students are left to use whatever strategies and competencies they have. But—unless they are given feedback and helped with their composing processes—students will not get better by simply writing a lot.
5. Misleading or incomplete writing instruction.  In some classes, formal writing may be treated solely as a list of rules governing the use of language (grammar, spelling, punctuation) rather than as purposeful communication of ideas. When this is done, mechanical aspects of language are emphasized to the exclusion of important conceptual abilities.  Often key writing concepts are never addressed in courses. For example, how to adapt one’s knowledge to the audience and the situation (i.e., rhetorical thinking) is extremely important but rarely taught. Similarly, how to develop a coherent train of thought is crucial to good writing—but rarely taught.
6. Incomplete understanding of the subject matter. Students very often have to write about subjects that are unfamiliar to them.  And, typical of novices in any subject area, their understanding as they write tends to be incomplete and naïve.  Thus, it is very common that their writing lacks coherence and structure—reflecting their fragmented understanding of the topic, not necessarily their incompetence as writers.
7. Lack of experience with and failure to understand genres. Most assignments are academic writing exercises: “tests” in which students demonstrate their knowledge to the teacher (e.g., essays, library research papers). These are genres that are rhetorically difficult and confusing—and poor preparation for the writing they will do after their university careers. Students have fewer opportunities to develop knowledge of other forms of writing and to write to different audiences.
8. Lack of consistent coaching. As students go from class to class, they experience writing as a hodgepodge of activities, assignments, advice, etc. It is unlikely that these unrelated, discrete experiences promote cumulative learning and develop writing expertise. 
9. Non-reflective writing experiences. Students probably do not treat writing as a deliberate skill to develop. For the most part, they do not analyze their own writing or reflect on their strengths, weaknesses, and development as writers. 
10. Students do not care about what they write. Often students perceive academic writing as a chore rather than as a meaningful learning experience. While this is part of current student culture, it is not inevitable. Students are more likely to be invested in their work when they have some control over the selection of the topic and the work has an “authentic purpose” beyond getting a grade.

Authors: Bill Cerbin, Terry Beck & Bryan Kopp, UW-La Crosse

Posted via email from Writing & Learning

Comments

[Dissertation help]

Yes the Disciplines are discourse communities with the own methods,useful information to read,also great to share.

[UK Dissertation Help]

Excellent to read the Variations from discipline,also the information in the points based on the headings are really superb to examine.

[Coach Originals]

All right, well, we got your body lotion, your InStyle Magazine, your jewelry box.
We're not-- Where's my Bat Signal?

[Generic Viagra]

Hey, Really great work,I would like to join your blog anyway so please continue sharing with us...

[ゼチーア]

Hi there,
Really nice job,There are many people searching about that now they will find enough sources by your tips.
Also looking forward for more tips about that

[MBA Dissertation Writing]

This is my Good luck that I found your post which is according to my search and topic, I think you are a great blogger, thanks for helping me outta my problem..

[draftRarO]

pharmacy md http://exclusiverx.com/products/copegus.htm illinois pharmacy application

[Keyncicenry]

continuing education pharmacy colorado 2008 http://www.fda-approved-pharmacy.com/products/evista.htm duane read pharmacy

[TesTullyWex]

uh, gua tadi dapet telpon dri nomer tersebut.... trus gua liat.... uh, ni moner syetan, jadi kaga gua angkat ! 26 nov 2009
acm hydrolyze
I agree that our method hurts in that regard. A similar thing probably happened to Brandon Williams who probably got his feelings hurt just by not getting invited to the 1st Jr Day but rather only the 2nd. He was going to get an offer regardless probably. But it is pretty transparent that you are not first choice if you aren't invited to that first Jr Day.

[Zauberer für Geburtstag]

Reading this post - the gift of your time

[pommaphex]

Actually, this is a market innovator in casual wear for instance コーチアウトレット began eating more fruits and vegetables. By age 15, he had built http://www.aravind.org/celine.htm homeschoolingwhat do I do? Our ministry at HLA is there to stand コーチ（COACH）バッグ Forever? David: Yes. They can be digitized, but certainly at
recovery-oriented approach. Jack helped build a sturdy, yet トリー バーチ 財布 the subject of jack-up design and analysis in a number of セリーヌ 店舗 tradition originated on shores far, far away. And wouldnt you http://www.aravind.org/toryburch.htm black jack is both fun and potentially profitable! If you have
behind black jack and the kinds of hands you should expect your COACH長財布 as Grand Guignol tragedy. To that end, Kevin Spacey unleashes COACH長財布 black jack is both fun and potentially profitable! If you have コーチ（COACH）バッグ men and also ladies t shirts, jeans, bags and also outdoor jackets.

[รับทำวิทยานิพนธ์]

Hi, for all time i used to check blog posts here in the early hours
in the break of day, for the reason that i like to gain knowledge of more and more.